Dual Struggles: Understanding How Mental Health Issues Drive Substance Use

Nov 9, 2024 | Melissa Barakat, Mental health

By Melissa Barakat

Guest author | Medical student at Saint George University of Beirut

One in four adults with mental health disorders also struggle with substance use. Common mental health conditions that often co-occur with substance use include depression, anxiety disorders, bipolar disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Why Do Those with Mental Health Disorders Abuse Substances?

People with mental health disorders frequently turn to alcohol and drugs to cope with challenging emotions, alleviate distress, or self-medicate their symptoms. Here’s how different mental health conditions may drive substance use:

  • Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD): Individuals with SAD may turn to alcohol or other substances to ease the anxiety associated with social situations, like meeting new people.
  • Schizophrenia: Those with schizophrenia may use substances in attempts to manage symptoms or to counter the sedative effects of antipsychotic medications. However, recent studies indicate that substance use is often driven by a desire to manage negative emotional states, such as social anxiety, dysphoria, and depression.
  • Depression: Many people dealing with depression use drugs or alcohol to numb symptoms or seek a temporary mood boost. The changes in brain chemistry can increase the rewarding effects of substances, leading to a higher likelihood of ongoing use.

The Science of Self-Medication
Research from the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) indicates that changes in brain function due to mental health disorders can amplify the rewarding effects of substances. This makes it more likely for individuals with these disorders to develop patterns of continued substance use, often leading to addiction and worsening mental health​. 

Common Risk Factors for Co-Occurring Disorders

There are several risk factors that can contribute to the development of both mental health issues and substance use disorders:

  • Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs): Experiencing abuse, neglect, or a lack of supportive relationships in childhood can increase vulnerability to substance abuse and mental health disorders.
  • Biological Vulnerabilities: A family history of mental illness or substance use disorders increases risk.
  • Trauma or PTSD: Experiencing traumatic events like war, violence, or natural disasters can significantly raise the likelihood of substance use.                    
  • Psychosocial Stressors: Life challenges, such as divorce or chronic illness, can also increase susceptibility to both mental health disorders and substance use.

Symptoms of Substance Use Disorders

Behavioral Changes

  • Decreased attendance or poor performance at work or school.
  • Frequent legal or social troubles.
  • Secretive behaviors, mood swings.
  • Lack of motivation and unexplained anxiety.

Physical Changes

  • Bloodshot eyes, unusual pupil size.
  • Sudden weight changes and decline in personal appearance.
  • Impaired coordination and slurred speech.

Social Changes

  • Changes in friendships, activities, or hobbies. 
  • Legal and financial issues.
  • Continuing substance use despite relationship difficulties.

Effective Strategies for Managing Co-Occurring Disorders

Managing both mental health and substance use disorders is essential for successful recovery. Treatments often involve a combination of behavioral therapies, medications, and support groups. Here are some effective options:

  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): Helps individuals confront and cope with irrational thoughts and modify unhealthy behaviors.
  • Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT): Focuses on mindfulness, emotional regulation, and stress management, particularly useful for individuals with personality disorders or intense emotional responses.
  • Assertive Community Treatment (ACT): A community-centered approach that tailors treatment plans to individual needs and emphasizes outreach.
  • Additional Strategies for Long-Term Management
  • Early Diagnosis and Integrated Care: The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) emphasizes early diagnosis and integrated treatment as keys to managing dual diagnosis effectively. Both disorders should be treated simultaneously to reduce the risk of relapse and support overall health.
  • Self-Care and Support Networks: Encourage a healthy lifestyle, engaging in regular exercise, maintaining social connections, and avoiding isolation. Support groups and peer networks provide a foundation for sharing experiences and building resilience.

Final Thoughts

The connection between mental health disorders and substance use is both complex and significant. Conditions like depression and anxiety can drive individuals to use substances to cope, often exacerbating both their mental health issues and addiction. Breaking this cycle requires a holistic approach to treating both disorders together.

Understanding the connection between mental health and addiction is essential for individuals, families, and healthcare providers. With early intervention, integrated care, and supportive treatment, recovery is possible. Recognizing these patterns is a powerful first step on the path to healing.